Question Details

avatar
Welcome to the Acrobat Answers site. You're on your way! It won't take you many more points to reach the next level: Participant. And as you accumulate more points, you're also building your reputation with the community and with AcrobatUsers.com.

Alternate text that will never be read

I created a Span, with Alt text for a large block of text containing phone #s and locations. I ran an Accessibility Full check. Got 7 "Alternate text that will never be read." All refer to a space after a word, e.g., "Pediatrics" in "Family/Internal Medicine, O.B.G.Y.N., Pediatrics 408-848-4095.". The space is in a Span without Alt text. That Span is within my Span with Alt text . ROL reads my Alt text perfectly.

As there is no Alt text attached to these error Spans (which are within the "Alt text Span") is this a major problem?

Acrobat X:Associating Page Content with Alternate Text

Alternate text should always be an alternate representation for content on the page. If an element has alternate text but does not contain any page content, there is no way to determine which page it is on. If the Screen Reader Option in the Reading preferences is not set to read the entire document, the alternate text will never be read by screen readers. Find the associated page content and add it to the element with the alternate text. See the hint for Adding Alternate Text.


KATHLEEN MCGUINNESS 844 days ago


4 Answers

Voted Best Answer

avatar
<p>Congratulations! The Acrobat User Community selection team has approved your status as Expert in the Acrobat User Community. We appreciate all your past contributions and hope you will continue to support the community by answering questions and participating in the Acrobat Answers Q&A program as you've done in the past.</p>

<p>As an expert, you will get a badge to display on your profile with the level EXPERT next to your name and you have become eligible to be nominated to the Adobe Community Professional Program.</p>

<p>After reviewing the Adobe Community Professional Program information at https://www.adobe.com/communities/professionals/, please let us know if you are interested.</p>

<p>Someone from the selection team will contact you soon regarding the community professional program. Keep up the good work!</p>

<p>Regards,</p>

<p>The Acrobat User Community Team</p>


<p>**** Disclosure Requirements for Endorsements Received by Third Parties  ****</p>

<p>If you endorse or refer people to the Acrobat User Community in any venue,  it is our responsibility to ensure that you are aware of required compliance with the <a href="http://ftc.gov/os/2009/10/091005revisedendorsementguides.pdf">FTC’s Guidelines</a>. Both you and Adobe can be held liable under federal law for making unsubstantiated claims and for not disclosing your relationship with Adobe. In particular:</p>

<ol>
<li>Always disclose if you have received any type of incentive – free products, promotional items, travel, gifts, payment, and so on from Adobe. The disclosure must be on the same page as the endorsement.</li>
<li>Be truthful. Endorsements should not be misleading. Never make unsubstantiated or exaggerated claims about the benefits of Adobe products or programs. Any statements or endorsements about an Adobe product must be based on upon your actual experience.</li>
</ol>

Thank you again for your support of Adobe and the Acrobat User Community</p>

It would be easier to understand if you could share the PDF.

Be well...


By David Austin answered 743 days ago  |   Comments (0)  |  New Comment

avatar

  |   Report
Was this answer helpful?  
3
0

avatar
Welcome to the Acrobat Answers site. You're on your way! It won't take you many more points to reach the next level: Participant. And as you accumulate more points, you're also building your reputation with the community and with AcrobatUsers.com.

http://mcgraphics.us/pdf/WereHearforYou_DavidAustin.pdf

This is the accessible brochure that went to the Client. We didn't do the design as brochure went to printer. Did do some InDesign 5.5 production revision, articles, lists, setting up tags in paragraph styles. The rest had to be done in Acrobat 10.

• A lot of alt text. Instead of using <span> tags I've used the top level of the block of text, page 2 & 3 in the pdf.
• Table to be alt text so I used <figure> with alt text
• Client didn't want hyperlinks

There are comments pdf.

Any suggestions would be great.
It's still a challenge to figure out what to do as OS 10.6.8, Acrobat 10's Read OutLoud only reads alt text accurately in read page mode, not in read line by line..


KATHLEEN MCGUINNESS answered 741 days ago  |   Comments (0)  |  New Comment

avatar

  |   Report
Was this answer helpful?  
1
0

avatar
<p>Congratulations! The Acrobat User Community selection team has approved your status as Expert in the Acrobat User Community. We appreciate all your past contributions and hope you will continue to support the community by answering questions and participating in the Acrobat Answers Q&A program as you've done in the past.</p>

<p>As an expert, you will get a badge to display on your profile with the level EXPERT next to your name and you have become eligible to be nominated to the Adobe Community Professional Program.</p>

<p>After reviewing the Adobe Community Professional Program information at https://www.adobe.com/communities/professionals/, please let us know if you are interested.</p>

<p>Someone from the selection team will contact you soon regarding the community professional program. Keep up the good work!</p>

<p>Regards,</p>

<p>The Acrobat User Community Team</p>


<p>**** Disclosure Requirements for Endorsements Received by Third Parties  ****</p>

<p>If you endorse or refer people to the Acrobat User Community in any venue,  it is our responsibility to ensure that you are aware of required compliance with the <a href="http://ftc.gov/os/2009/10/091005revisedendorsementguides.pdf">FTC’s Guidelines</a>. Both you and Adobe can be held liable under federal law for making unsubstantiated claims and for not disclosing your relationship with Adobe. In particular:</p>

<ol>
<li>Always disclose if you have received any type of incentive – free products, promotional items, travel, gifts, payment, and so on from Adobe. The disclosure must be on the same page as the endorsement.</li>
<li>Be truthful. Endorsements should not be misleading. Never make unsubstantiated or exaggerated claims about the benefits of Adobe products or programs. Any statements or endorsements about an Adobe product must be based on upon your actual experience.</li>
</ol>

Thank you again for your support of Adobe and the Acrobat User Community</p>

Hi katm (thought it was you)
Got the PDF of pages.
A tip - to determine what ROL is reading do a save as to accessible text.
You'll note only the alt text provided for a Figure element will show.

You've got renderable text that is page content and it carries semantic content.
If content isn't actually something the Figure element is meant for don't at alt text.

Looking the pages over. I'll get back to you.

btw - You got the ISO authorized Adobe version of ISO 32000-1 (free), yes?
If not you do want it. Scroll down the web page at the link below. There is a link to it.

As you are wanting to provide accessible PDF you'll want ISO 14289-1:2012. (the ISO standard for PDF/UA).


http://www.aiim.org/Research-and-Publications/standards/committees/PDFUA/WCAG20
-Mapping


David Austin answered 740 days ago  |   Comments (1)  |  New Comment

avatar
Welcome to the Acrobat Answers site. You're on your way! It won't take you many more points to reach the next level: Participant. And as you accumulate more points, you're also building your reputation with the community and with AcrobatUsers.com.

I put WereHearforYou_DavidAustin.txt up for download at http://mcgraphics.us/pdf/David.html. All the alt text is there and reads perfectly.

Great reminder. I've tried this before, but tried MS Word for accessible text from pdf. That doesn't work, crashes.

I'll download PDF you'll want ISO 14289-1:2012

KATHLEEN MCGUINNESS Commented 739 days ago  |   Report


avatar

  |   Report
Was this answer helpful?  
3
0

avatar
Welcome to the Acrobat Answers site. You're on your way! It won't take you many more points to reach the next level: Participant. And as you accumulate more points, you're also building your reputation with the community and with AcrobatUsers.com.

I added a link to the accessible .tx at http://mcgraphics.us/pdf/David.html. Text shows all alt text and figure text. I've used this before. Very cool feature. Nice on a small brochure like this, but it gets really confusing on our 100 page books, because there are no page #s. I've tried save as accessible text MS Word. Doesn't work and crashes often. When it goes thru no page #s, so figuring out where you are is impossible.

Your comment: Alternate text should always be an alternate representation for content on the page

You mean Alt text needs to have a visual on the page, e.g. TOC shows on the page and then can have alt text?

If so am I doing ok to add alt text to the top level <l> in properties?


KATHLEEN MCGUINNESS answered 739 days ago  |   Comments (0)  |  New Comment

avatar

  |   Report
Was this answer helpful?  
1
0


Download
Acrobat XI trial

Get the trial now


Other Questions Needing Answers


Sort dates in table

Asked by Yvette Pennant · 1 answer